0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.
Quote from: DonnyBazR0ver on March 02, 2019, 09:20:30 pmQuote from: Filo on March 02, 2019, 09:09:10 pmQuote from: DonnyBazR0ver on March 02, 2019, 09:01:38 pmI've just seen it back, freeze framed it 3 times and it's a close call. When the ball is kicked, Rowe is just onside and May is off. When Rowe heads the ball, he's marginally in an offside position however the presence of May, might have blurred things for the Linesman, maybe not sure who got the final touch, and/or if May obscuring the view of the keeper.In real time, if you asked 10 of us to view that, there would not be 10 correct decisions. Baz have you been on the pop, May is nowhere near the keeper, if Rowe is onside when Marquis kicks it he can never be offside regardless of where he is when he touches the ball. It wasn’t the only one thatlino got wrong, he was a disgraceI'm looking at it from the linesman perspective at ground level. It's an incorrect decision no doubt but we've seen them called wrong before and we'll seen them called wrong again. Nobody seems to be calling the linesman who didn't give a goal for Peterbrough the other week, a cheat when it went over the line. And what about the dubious penalty signalled by the linesman in the Oldham game recently? As I recall there were quite a few of Rovers’ fans who were very doubtful about the decision. Can’t recall any of them accusing him of being bent or a cheat.
Quote from: Filo on March 02, 2019, 09:09:10 pmQuote from: DonnyBazR0ver on March 02, 2019, 09:01:38 pmI've just seen it back, freeze framed it 3 times and it's a close call. When the ball is kicked, Rowe is just onside and May is off. When Rowe heads the ball, he's marginally in an offside position however the presence of May, might have blurred things for the Linesman, maybe not sure who got the final touch, and/or if May obscuring the view of the keeper.In real time, if you asked 10 of us to view that, there would not be 10 correct decisions. Baz have you been on the pop, May is nowhere near the keeper, if Rowe is onside when Marquis kicks it he can never be offside regardless of where he is when he touches the ball. It wasn’t the only one thatlino got wrong, he was a disgraceI'm looking at it from the linesman perspective at ground level. It's an incorrect decision no doubt but we've seen them called wrong before and we'll seen them called wrong again. Nobody seems to be calling the linesman who didn't give a goal for Peterbrough the other week, a cheat when it went over the line.
Quote from: DonnyBazR0ver on March 02, 2019, 09:01:38 pmI've just seen it back, freeze framed it 3 times and it's a close call. When the ball is kicked, Rowe is just onside and May is off. When Rowe heads the ball, he's marginally in an offside position however the presence of May, might have blurred things for the Linesman, maybe not sure who got the final touch, and/or if May obscuring the view of the keeper.In real time, if you asked 10 of us to view that, there would not be 10 correct decisions. Baz have you been on the pop, May is nowhere near the keeper, if Rowe is onside when Marquis kicks it he can never be offside regardless of where he is when he touches the ball. It wasn’t the only one thatlino got wrong, he was a disgrace
I've just seen it back, freeze framed it 3 times and it's a close call. When the ball is kicked, Rowe is just onside and May is off. When Rowe heads the ball, he's marginally in an offside position however the presence of May, might have blurred things for the Linesman, maybe not sure who got the final touch, and/or if May obscuring the view of the keeper.In real time, if you asked 10 of us to view that, there would not be 10 correct decisions.
No one seems to have mentioned the delay to the Lino flagging offside. Now I always look instantly at the lino when we score to make sure there’s no offside. The goal was scored the players ran away to celebrate - I looked straight at the lino and no flag. Goal, we nicked the game at the death, probably not deserving all 3 points but f*ck it, we’ve lost plenty we should have won. Then, a good few seconds later I glance back at the lino and his flag is up. F*ck me does it take 10 seconds for that tiny, stacking f*ck*ng shelves for the rest of the week, hobby f*ck*ng Lino’s brain to take so long to decide someone is offside and steal the goal. If he wasn’t sure then, surely, benefit of doubt should go to the scorer! It’s time refs were professional and not doing it for a hobby. How much money is at stake in these games and we have, at best, incompetent tw*ts, at worst cheats, deciding the results of games like this. F*ck*ng furious at being robbed in full daylight of 3 points. And the useless c*nt will be officiating again next week - Pity the poor b*st*rd unsuspecting fans who get him! Rant over, too much rum commiserating one of the worst pieces of officiating I’ve seen in years. Going to bed!!!!!!
No and I don’t need clues, I can read too; and you missed out ‘give’ to make that sentence mean something, just saying like!!!
Someone has posted a video on FB from im guessing the bottom corner of the southstand. When Marquis shoots Rowe is easily 2 yards on and May is level at worst. The shot is clearly glanced in via Tommy"s head.Incredible decision.Surprised not much mentioned either about the stonewall penalty when Alfie Shot.Defender might as well have caught it.
Hang on.Rowe was about 10m from Marquis. If it took the ball 0.02s to get that distance, it must have been travelling at 500m/s, which is roughly 1000mph.I know Marquis can leather a ball, but there's limits.
No penalty on wilks in 2nd half?https://youtu.be/6HxPIx0Xals (13m13s)
The video also shows you how quick it happened and at the linesman level he couldn't have been sure who touched it but in a split second both looked offside. I can understand how he made the mistake. It was a close call.
Said same to my dad as we walked out ref didn't want Charlton to lose efl want London clubs up but not little clubs like Donny in there
The thing that gets me when people talk about officials cheating is this, in every league most of the calls go to the same teams. Portsmouth, Sunderland, Barnsley, Peterborough, Charlton, Doncaster, realistically, at the moment, unless one comes out of the pack one will go up with Luton the other five are going for four places. Who is the smallest club most likely to get the rough end of the stick out of that lot. Most of them have already had some iffy decisions against us already this season.
Quote from: BillyStubbsTears on March 02, 2019, 11:54:07 pmHang on.Rowe was about 10m from Marquis. If it took the ball 0.02s to get that distance, it must have been travelling at 500m/s, which is roughly 1000mph.I know Marquis can leather a ball, but there's limits. Watch the footage and look at the timer!
Officials should be 100% sure before making a decision of that importance. If they have any doubt whatsoever regarding an infringement they shouldn't call one. The linesman involved in yesterday's incident must have made the decision based on uncertainty because he was certainly wrong.
Quote from: Bentley Bullet on March 03, 2019, 01:37:37 pmOfficials should be 100% sure before making a decision of that importance. If they have any doubt whatsoever regarding an infringement they shouldn't call one. The linesman involved in yesterday's incident must have made the decision based on uncertainty because he was certainly wrong.Yeah and it cost me a point in the PvO competition as well.
Quote from: drfchound on March 03, 2019, 04:52:41 pmQuote from: Bentley Bullet on March 03, 2019, 01:37:37 pmOfficials should be 100% sure before making a decision of that importance. If they have any doubt whatsoever regarding an infringement they shouldn't call one. The linesman involved in yesterday's incident must have made the decision based on uncertainty because he was certainly wrong.Yeah and it cost me a point in the PvO competition as well.And me!